Hungarian Social and Economic Attitudes in 2009
Civic minded citizens economic leaders hired Tárki to conduct a survey of Hungarian society’s attitude toward cultural values and the general state of societal interactions. The impetus for the study was the recognition that social attitudes have an impact even on the country’s competitive advantage. That competitive advantage, especially of late, has been waning. Those who ordered the survey wanted to know the cause of this decline. Tárki used the framework of the World Value Survey to come up with The Normative Limits of the Market Economy (Economic Culture). The World Values Survey is an ongoing academic project by social scientists to assess the state of sociocultural, moral, religious and political values of different cultures around the world.
There are some surprises in Tárki’s findings. For example, “given the level of economic development, the Hungarian value system is more secularized” than countries of a similar background. By “secularization” Tárki means that Hungarians are less prone to follow the precepts of authority or those of a traditional society. Thus, they are rather individualistic.
Social scientists also wanted to know how important for members of Hungarian society are such values as self-fulfillment, democracy, openness, trust, tolerance, civic cooperation, personal contacts, and use of democratic institutions. In this respect Hungary was placed at the very edge of the western, Christian cultural sphere and showed itself to be a closed, inward-looking society. Hungarian readers of the assessment might be offended because Hungary is placed closer to countries like Bulgaria, Moldavia, Ukraine and Russia than to Slovenia or other countries west of Hungary.
Hungarians find civil and political rights less important than people in countries west of Hungary. They are less interested in daily politics and are less likely to take an active part in the political life of the country. They are less tolerant of opinions that are contrary to the accepted norms of the majority. They are also less trusting.
As far as trust goes, Hungary finds itself between western Europe and the former socialist states when it comes to trusting individuals. However, Hungary is the very last of all European countries, including the former socialist states, in trusting institutions. The distrust in political institutions is most likely especially high because of the real and assumed corruption of politicians. However, Hungarians have put little stock in state and local institutions in general for centuries. Trust is especially low in those on whom one should rely: politicians, bankers, and journalists. After all, politicians are supposed to make decisions affecting our future, bankers are entrusted with our money, and journalists are supposed to inform us accurately.
Another surprising finding is that there is little human intercourse in Hungary. People don’t often entertain or organize outings with their friends. They are also not too eager to help each other. Very few people belong to different civil organizations, clubs, or some kind of charitable organization.
Two-thirds of Hungarians think that they themselves are honest but others are not. Interestingly enough, that attitude is coupled with an unusual tolerance toward those who break the law.
As far as the difference between the highest and the lowest income brackets is concerned, Hungary belongs to the average among European countries. However, Hungarians are convinced that the gap between rich and poor is “too great”. Actually much greater than in reality. And one more telling finding: among fifty countries, the Hungarians are the most convinced that economic success can be achieved only at someone else’s expense. In other words, “I’m poor because someone else is rich.” Economic cooperation is unlikely in a country where the majority of the population thinks that wealth accumulation is a zero sum game. It causes Hungarians to drag others down to their level, rather than rise to the challenge.
The percentage of those who think that educational attainment is a key to success is very low. The common belief is that success in life has more to do with one’s social background than with one’s actual achievements. Hungarians are utterly convinced that “one cannot succeed in life if he is honest.” Only crooks make it to the top. A very unhealthy attitude that is not at all conducive to the appreciation of economic success.
The survey also proved that the “Hungarian population is very prone to expect results offered by state intervention.” The average Hungarian citizen even demands benefits from the state that he himself knows the state cannot provide.
This anti-entreprenurial, distrustful mindset, the authors conclude, is deeply rooted in the Hungarian cultural/historical tradition. It has only been reinforced by the social philosophy of the intellectual and political elite. It is going to be very difficult to change these societal attitudes. Is is a sad thing that Hungary is wasting such a great amount of potential. Almost all of the great Hungarian success stories, from billionaires to Nobel prize winners to mathematicians, have not been successful until they left Hungary.
When one looks at this on a comparative perspective over the last fifteen years, however, it has not always been this way. A decade or more ago, on almost all of these objective criteria, Hungarians seemed far ahead of the Czechs and Poles, and by many measures it appeared that the Hungarian transition to liberal democracy would be significantly smoother than in these other countries.
The massive wave of liberalization and privatization in Hungary in the early to mid 1990’s did not provoke a huge outcry and a fracturing of the society (at least immediately). In many ways things really were looking up for Hungary for a while.
Current saddening tendencies therefore are hopefully rather temporary and show current frustrations of the people. The heavily polarized nature of politics had a strongly corrosive effect on society and on the population’s attitudes to institutions.
Economy will turn around eventually. Whether politics will, is a bigger question.
Sources: Tárki Institue, World Value Survey, Hungarian Spectrum
Hungarian cultural values, societal interactions, social attitudes, competitive advantage, economic culture, sociocultural values, moral values, religious values, political values
National pride
A few days ago Tárki, a polling company, together with Image Factory, a firm offering “political and business solutions,” looked into the question of national pride and the nation’s self image.
Three years ago 40% of all Hungarians were proud of being Hungarian. Today, only 32%.
This question of national pride has always puzzled me. Where we are born and what language we learn as infants is really happenstance. Something over which we have no control. Why anyone should feel pride because of it is beyond me. Especially if we try to flesh out the basis of this pride. Read more »
Quality of a Leader
Where will the Hungarian soul take the nation from this point forward?
Hungarians have used their freedom to change governments well. In the second half of the 20th century Hungarians had very few opportunities to change governments. Since the change from the long time communist government Read more »
Are Hungarians Antisemitic?
One of the things I discovered without looking for it was that in conversation about money, many Hungarians would complain about Jews. My first question was “why?”
This led me to do some research on the history of the relationship between Hungarians and Jews. Read more »
Payback Ethic
One Hungarian value that this author and many foreigners noticed was something called the payback ethic. Throughout the world people will treat others in return the way they are treated, but Hungarians seem to take this farther than others. One person said, “It is hard to do a favor for Hungarians Read more »
“Women Scandalously Dressed”
Two missionaries felt that Hungarians have a spiritual crisis in sentimental relationships. Overplayed sexual overtones Read more »
Obsession with the Past, Racism, Violence
A British diplomat brought out the Hungarian historical memory saying, “Why are they so obsessed with themselves and their sad history? They keep talking about Trianon as if it was yesterday, he said.” Read more »
Does God Play Games with Us?
The Austrian Army officers clinked their glasses of beer as they drank to celebrate the execution of the Hungarian patriots who fought for freedom. It is no wonder that Hungarians do not clink their beer glasses when they toast each other’s health! Read more »
Where was God, When My Child Died?
“He punished us for our sins, past and future.” – this is a quote from the Hungarian National Anthem written in the 19th century. Hungarians hold on to this particular theology to this day.
I hadn’t seen one of my Hungarian friends for a while and as we met I asked, “How are you?” Americans treat this question as a greeting, and regardless of how they are doing, usually answer, “Fine.” Read more »
Popular Theology: Common Beliefs About God in Hungary
The most famous Hungarian theological statement is the National Hymn- “God bless the Hungarian.” Theology simply means, “Ideas regarding God.” And this work contains lots of theology, which is recited by many Hungarians more times than they say the Lord’s prayer. Read more »
Rebuilt, and Rebuilt Again
In the mid 70’s I had a colleague in university named Bill Dabas. He used to drink a certain ice tea that came in a green can (He used to collect the cans so we could say Dabas liked to collect the Doboz [Hungarian for can] as a little play on words). He would stack the cans against the wall of his dormitory room. Read more »
Hungarian is a way of life
Hungarians have never built pyramids, ruled slave empires, and conquered new worlds. They are a proud, strange and lonely people.
Read more »
Hungarian Humanism
How does humanism reveal itself in Hungarian history and civilization?
Hungarians have always been known for their thirst for knowledge: an important humanistic attribute. Their attitude towards foreign cultures has always been that of sympathetic curiosity: they accepted their inspiration and adapted them to their own tastes. Read more »
Keeping One’s Given Word
Personal and national honor or integrity is a cardinal virtue in the Hungarian moral spectrum. Keeping one’s given word is an obligation overriding most other considerations, including political expediency. This is why the Hungarians never changed sides during international conflicts, however advantageous it may have been to do so. Read more »
Defenders of Christian Europe?
Hungarians like calling themselves the “Defenders of Christian Europe’ for having fought the eastern and southern pagan aggressors for a thousand years. Read more »
Living on the Borderlines of Europe
Where do the fundamental traits of the different European cultures come from?
The dotted lines on the map of Europe are in many cases the product of historical accident: primarily acts of violence, but also dynastic marriages or sheer happenstance. Still, our frontiers rarely conform to the cultural realities. Read more »
Knowledge: Quality of Life
Knowledge means quality of life (the life we can only live once), gives the person a feeling of competence, and carries the hope of future.
Knowledge is highly valued is Hungarian society, but in the young generation, a materialistic value-system is developing due to the social and existential crisis in Central-Eastern Europe.
Knowledge is also seen as a tool for Hungarian society to be able to compete in the world arena. Science is the 4th element of power in the world today (after military power / force, economy / money, and media / information).
Authority and Leadership: The Ideal Boss in Hungary
International businessmen and missionaries alike typically come with the misconception that Hungary (as a CEE country) must be a high-authority, hierarchic society, and try to work under this assumption. Read more »
Woody Allen and the Hungarian Psyche
Hungarians easily identify with Woody Allen who said:
“I have a persecution complex – because I’m persecuted.”
Read more »
What Friendship Means
Introducing someone as a “friend” communicates more commitment to the Hungarian than what you probably mean using this word, especially if you come from the North American culture. Read more »
The Little Prince and the Fox
It was then that the fox appeared.
“Good morning,” said the fox.
“Good morning,” the little prince responded politely, although when he turned around he saw nothing.
“I am right here,” the voice said, “under the apple tree.”
“Who are you?” asked the little prince, and added, “You are very pretty to look at.” Read more »
Hungarian Culture: Why it is as it is?
Hungarian culture (due to its location and history) has always been at the crossroads between eastern and western cultures, has functioned as a bridge between East and West, integrating characteristic features of both. What is Hungarian culture like? Read more »
How They Tell You’re Smart
Cross cultural comparisons in the areas of geography, national history, values, faith and religion, adaptability to change, making a difference, the measures of success, wearing social walls, signs of bright-mindedness, behavior toward foreigners.
Read more »
Spiritual Climate
The people of Budapest tend to be receptive when time is taken to establish personal credibility and trust. Street evangelism tends to repel people where no prior relationship exists. Freedom to cross-denominational boundaries (whether real or perceived) is not granted easily by one’s family or even one’s own conscience. The respect for denominational tradition is a real issue. Read more »
Christian Heritage?
Christianity was first introduced to the Magyar people through a pact made by King István with the Vatican in 1000 AD. After officially declaring Hungary to be a Christian nation in order to form closer political ties to the growing West, people were given the choice to convert to Christianity or forfeit their lives.
Read more »
Religious Affiliaton of Hungarians
Cultural Catholic Christianity is the stated traditional religion of the people in Budapest. The years of Communism (1949 – 1989) had quite an affect on the mentality of the modern-day Hungarian.
Read more »
Roots of Hungarian Character
The Hungarian Character
We shall find it easier to understand the history and civilization of the Hungarians, if we look at first at some interesting traits of their national character.
Read more »
